Monday, January 15, 2007

Finished the Read through!

Finally, I am getting to make my observations regarding the book I read over the holidays. I should have done this when I was on holidays!!

The Three-Minute Classroom Walk-Through by Carolyn J. Downey, Steffy, English, Frase and Poston.

Our admin group is examining ways to assist in the development of teacher supervision that contributes to the growth of the teacher while still providing an opportunity of the administrator to look at other options if the need arises. The method that is explained in TMCWT does provide an excellent framework for administrators to use with teachers that goes beyond the traditional style of supervision/evaluation.

Throughout the book, it is stressed that the goal is to move from corrective supervision to reflective supervision that invites the teacher to reflect on what they are doing, examine what they are doing, seek new information and incorporate this new information into their present knowledge, creating a new knowledge that they can use. The whole framework is based on a constructivist pedagogy.

Now, I have outlined many of the chapters and given brief summaries. At this time, I wish to look at how I think this format might be useful in assisting teachers with their professional growth, helping administrators begin to know the curriculum content across the grades and reinforce the collaborative nature of teaching.

The main framework of the Walk-Through is the observation process. The process is expected to take 3 minutes, no longer. It is meant to be done with little to no interruption of the class and the principal is to remain no longer than this time in the class. This may not seem like a long time but once the administrator has become efficient in using the framework, the process should not take much longer.

Framework - found in chapter 2 of the book - quick overview of the Five-Step Walk-Through Observation Structure - p. 21

Step 1 - Student Orientation to the Work - Do students appear to be attending when you first walk into the room?
Step 2 - Curricular Decision Points - What objective(s) has the teacher chosen to teach at this time and how aligned are they to the prescribed (provincial) written curriculum? This is examined in three areas: Content - the skill, knowledge, process, concept to be learned by the students. Context - The conditions under which students will demonstrate the learning (eg, student mode of response, materials and information given to them orally or in writing? Cognitive Type - Knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, evaluation or creation! (Bloom et al., 1956)
What is the listed or stated objective?
Calibration - Course of study - provincial curriculum - where is the objective found in the provincial curriculum?
Step 3 - Instructional Decsion Points - What instructional practices is the teacher choosing to use at this time to help students achieve the learning of the curriculum objectives?
Determine the generic instructional decisions being made. Generic practices are those that could be used regardless of student age or subject area (eg. comparing and contrasting, feedback, using examples, non-linguistic representations)
Identify strategies being used at a specific school and/or district focus.
Observe specific research-based, subject-specific practices such as the use of meta-cognitive strategies, manipulatives or mental computations in math.
Step 4 - "Walk-the-Walls": Curricular and Instructional Decisions - What evidence is ther of past objectives taught and/or instrucutional decsions used to teach the objectives that are present in the classroom - walk-the-walls, portfolios, projects in the room?
Step 5 - Safety and Health Issues - Are there any noticeable safety or health issues that need to be addressed?

In Chapter 2 each of these is described in greater detail to help administrators understand what it is they are to be looking for when they make this short visit.

Another important part to the walk through is not to make judgements about the teaching practices. One is to notice what is happening, make note of it, find its corresponding reference but do not make judgements that the teacher is not doing what they are suppose to be doing. You are seeing only 3 minutes of the entire lesson and the teacher could be using these strategies or curriculum points for a variety of reasons.

One thing that I liked about the book was the review of the major points that is found at the end of each chapter. I found that these helped me to focus on the main ideas and to refocus what I had read before moving on to the next chapter. Also, when reviewing, it was easy to refresh my memory by going through these main points.

The walk-through is a method that moves away from the model of teacher supervision that is top down and instead builds on helping the teacher with their professional growth. The way that it is described in the book is the that the principal wants to move from dependent (direct) supervision, through Independent (indirect) to Interdependent (Collegial). The first stage is more for use with young teachers who may need direct guidance and advice as they begin their careers. It really is more like an adult talking to a child. The second stage is when the teacher is asked to reflect on the teaching that was observed and then the coach offers insights and may offer a reflective question for the teacher at the end of the conversation. This is similar to an adult and adolescent relationship. The last stage has the administrator posing a reflective question to the teacher and then, if the teacher wants, continuing the conversation at a later time.

I will be trying this out this upcoming week and I will post on how it worked. I know that it will feel artificial the first few times but I hope that after a few weeks people will get use to the way that this works.

Kelly

No comments: